Repository navigation
Child's private method is shown with overwrites A annotation in reflection #9409
Description
Description
Child's private method is shown with overwrites A annotation, which is misleading https://3v4l.org/dm3Y9
<?php
class A
{
private function privateMethod() {}
}
class C extends A {
private function privateMethod() {}
private function otherMethod() {}
}
$class = new ReflectionClass('C');
echo (string)$class->getMethod('privateMethod');
echo (string)$class->getMethod('otherMethod');Resulted in this output:
Method [ <user, overwrites A> private method privateMethod ] {
@@ /in/dm3Y9 7 - 7
}
Method [ <user> private method otherMethod ] {
@@ /in/dm3Y9 8 - 8
}
But I expected this output instead:
Method [ <user> private method privateMethod ] {
@@ /in/dm3Y9 7 - 7
}
Method [ <user> private method otherMethod ] {
@@ /in/dm3Y9 8 - 8
}
/cc @damianwadley
PHP Version
8.0 - 8.2
Operating System
No response
Reacted by simapple
Activity
damianwadley commentedon Aug 24, 2022
Like with 64592, this is probably something that can't be fixed (if that decision is made) until PHP 9.
iluuu1994 commentedon Sep 2, 2022
Fix for the latter part: #9469
I'll create a new issue for the former part so we have separate GitHub issue IDs that can be referenced.
[-]Inconsistency with ReflectionMethod[/-][+]Child's `private` method is shown with `overwrites A` annotation in reflection[/+]Private method incorrectly marked as "overwrites" in reflection